![tng measure of a man tng measure of a man](https://trekmovie.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/ps-measure.jpg)
- Tng measure of a man full#
- Tng measure of a man android#
- Tng measure of a man series#
- Tng measure of a man free#
Tng measure of a man full#
Take Riker, for instance, whose competitive nature gets put through a full workout. The Associate Chair of Robotics at the Daystrom Institute needs no assistance to come off as a terrifying villain Data has greater power against a bat'leth or Borg nanites than being called by the pronoun "it." This is not just a story about big ideas but the smallest details of characterization and relationships. Snodgrass's entire screenplay.in fact, the only overdone element of the episode is the score, which ominously underscores Maddox's straightforward statement of his plans. This dialogue is subtle and brilliant, though the same might be said for Melinda M. Expendable people, Guinan suggests calmly, would make such dilemmas go away Starfleet would have an entire race of beings at its disposal, conveniently labeled property, to face the worst of the threats.
![tng measure of a man tng measure of a man](http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-YOW3cz4wQBE/UT-JKSbiMHI/AAAAAAAACNY/Pk7B20JiFo4/s1600/ST-TNG-10.jpg)
Picard mentions that he has sent humans into danger as great as that which Maddox proposes for Data. Maddox frames his project in terms of the greater moral good, creating additional androids to assist and protect humans from danger.
Tng measure of a man series#
As Guinan makes explicit to Picard, that question is so much bigger than the rights of Data, or Moriarty, or - to extrapolate into Star Trek's future - a series of emergency medical holograms. The story picks up where "Elementary, Dear Data" and "The Schizoid Man" each left off - the one leaving hanging the question of the rights of a sentient construct, the other honing in on the question of whether Data's rights are equivalent to those of a human.
Tng measure of a man free#
Louvois rules that while Data may be a machine, she does not have the authority to decide whether he has a soul, and he is free to make his own choices in life to discover that for himself.Īnalysis: One of the best episodes not only of The Next Generation but in all of Star Trek, "The Measure of a Man" distills all the things that make this series matter: seeking out new life and new civilizations, cherishing diversity, insisting on fairness and equality, understanding the value of friendship (or, where friendship is not possible, cooperation), overcoming fears and keeping a sense of humor through it all. Understanding that calling an intelligent being "property" is a euphemism for slavery, Picard insists that Data is no more property than children are the property of their parents and he should have the same right of self-determination. Devastated by Riker's performance, Picard tells Guinan of his certainty that he will be defeated, to which she suggests that maybe that's for the best - the Federation can create an entire race of disposable people to do dangerous or undesirable work. Forced to accept the position to avoid a summary ruling, Riker demonstrates that Data is a machine that can be switched off and argues that he was created to serve human needs. Louvois rules that the law favors Maddox's position the Federation and insists that in order to hold a hearing without a full staff, Picard will have to defend Data while Riker prosecutes the case.
![tng measure of a man tng measure of a man](https://www.denofgeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/star-trek-picard-episode-5-ending-explained-theories-scaled.jpg)
When Philipa Louvois, the Judge Advocate General who presided over his court martial after the loss of the Stargazer, suggests that Data's only option may be to resign, Data leaves Starfleet, but Maddox files a complaint stating that Data is not an individual but the property of Starfleet, just like the Enterprise computer.
Tng measure of a man android#
Data has serious reservations both because Maddox does not believe that an android is a sentient being and because he does not believe that Maddox has the skill to preserve his memories and consciousness. Plot Summary: Commander Bruce Maddox comes aboard the Enterprise during a visit to the new Starbase 173 with transfer orders for Data, whom he intends to disassemble in order to produce more androids for Starfleet. See Also: 'The Measure of a Man' Episode Guide